baking,  Blog,  Cakes,  Recipes - tried and tested

Tottenham Cake….

….just like Percy Ingles makes. To many people, well actually most people, Tottenham Cake and Percy Ingles means nothing, but work or live in the Eastend of London and you’ll know exactly what I’m talking about.

I worked in Hackney, in London’s East end for over 10 years, and was lucky to regularly enjoy delights from Percy Ingles Bakery, from ‘down the Roman Road’….and wow did they have some yummy delights. Percy Ingles is a household name in Hackney, but step away from the Capital and few people will know what you’re talking about. It is a family bakery with over 50 shops in London and makes a great classic Tottenham Cake.

Candy Club 

But what about Tottenham Cake – what is it, and why have you not heard of it? It even made an appearance on The Great British Bake Off, but still few people know what it is. I remember the first time I was bought a slice and it reminded me of cakes I used to eat as a child. It’s light, sweet sponge covered in bright pink glacé icing.

Delve a bit deeper, and it has real history. It was first made in the late 1800’s by a Baker called Henry Chalkley, who was a Quaker. He baked it in long trays and cut it into cubes which were sold for 1 penny a slice – off cuts and dodgy looking slices were sold for half a penny. As a Quaker, Henry kept the cake simple but tasty. The pink icing was reportedly made from Mulberries that grew in the garden of The Tottenham Friends Meeting House.

In 1901 Tottenham Hotspur’s won the FA Cup, and to celebrate children in the area were given a cube of cake for free… that’s my kind of celebration! Sadly Mulberries aren’t quite as easy to come by, and most of todays icing is made pink by colouring. But made well, it’s a cake that you just can’t resist….it’ll take you back to being 7 years old again.

Since living in Hampshire, I haven’t been able to find any, so have had to go about making some of my own. I’ve done my research and found a few historic recipes. I’ve combined and tweaked them, to make what I hope is a great, classic Tottenham Cake.  It’s slightly denser than a normal sponge, and is sweet and moist from the syrup that’s poured on it while warm. I used a high-concentrate, low sugar Summer Berry Squash for the icing, which gives it an extra fruity zing.


Tottenham Cake

170gms Softened Butter or Baking Spread

170gms Caster Sugar

3 Eggs

230gms Plain Flour

1.5tspn Baking Powder

1tspn Vanilla

50ml Cold water

2 tbspn Icing Sugar


For the Icing/Glaze

200gms Icing Sugar

1-2tbspn Mixed Berry Squash (not diluted)


Preheat Oven to 180c, (160c fan), 350f, Gas 3

Prepare a baking tin (approx 7″ square) by greasing and lining with parchment or grease-proof paper.

Using a hand mixer or stand mixer cream the butter and sugar until light and fluffy

Add the vanilla and one egg at a time and whisk until its thick and smooth.

Sift together the flour and baking powder, and fold into the wet ingredients.

Pour into the baking tin and bake for 30-40 minutes (until a cocktail stick stuck into the middle comes out clean)

Remove from the oven and set to one side. Mix together the icing sugar and water, until all the icing sugar has dissolved. Before removing the cake from the tin, use a spoon the drizzle the icing sugar syrup all over the top of the warm cake.

Carefully remove the cake from the tin and allow to cool on a wire rack.

Once cooled, mix 1tbspn of the fruit squash and all icing sugar to make a thick glace icing. You want a thick pourable consistency, if it’s too thin it’ll run right off your cake, however if its too thick and doesn’t pour at all, add a little extra liquid until it does.

Pour the icing onto the centre of the cake, and with a knife smooth to the sides. Allow to set for a few minutes before slicing and serving.


  • diane robinson

    I’m on the board of trustees for a non-profit group that is restoring an 1816 Quaker Meetinghouse in Farmington, new york, United States. I prepare most of the sweets for our open houses and tours. This has me interested in writing a Quaker cookbook to sell as a fund raiser. i have one quaker cookbook from the UK and wonder if there are more available or more recipes. I am including a large chapter on chocolate as it appears our Quaker ancesters had a lot to do with the Chocolate business. My direct ancester was William Wethersfield Comstock, who came to the United States in 1634. His father was William Constable and i think we go back to getting land from William the Conquerer (i want to prove this before i get too excited).
    My question, do you have any quaker recipes or cookbooks that i may purchase? We did have a Daisy flour here in the USA. It was a pastry flour and used for pie pastry and cookies (biscuits). I am surprised to find that strong flour (bread or gluten flour) was used for the thin pastry used for spanakopedia and other thin flakey pastry. i guess the gluten is necessary to hold it together.
    anyway, thanks for any help you can give. I am baking your cake this week.
    Diane Robinson, USA


      Sadly I only researched this particular cake because I’ve enjoyed eating it so much so wanted to know how to make it.
      Good luck with finding more recipes for your book though, let me know if you find any good ones.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *